## Sorares Value – Technology and Advancement – iGB
Sorare, the Ethereum-based digital collectible fantasy football league operator, has become a Web3 powerhouse, achieving widespread recognition rapidly. However, its business structure has attracted the attention of gambling authorities, reports Jacob Pollard.
**Sorare’s Worth**
Sorare’s accomplishment has been extraordinary. Established in 2018 by Nicolas Julia and Adrien Montfort, the enterprise is now valued at $4.2 billion (£3.4 billion/€4 billion). In September 2021, they secured a massive $680 million in funding.
Investors include some of the most prominent names in tech startups. SoftBank, Accel, Gary Vaynerchuk, and Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian, alongside renowned football stars like Rio Ferdinand and Antoine Griezmann, have all invested. And then there’s Kylian Mbappé, arguably the best player globally, who is also a brand representative for the company.
Sorare’s ascent has been met with commendation and backing from key figures in France. Besides having Mbappé on board, the company is the official Web3 token provider for the 2024 Paris Olympics. French executives and politicians have hailed it as a homegrown Web3 success story.
**Regulatory Issues**
Similar to fan token provider Socios and cryptocurrency trading behemoth Binance, Sorare has partnered with numerous sports clubs and leagues.
This agreement involves a substantial annual partnership worth thirty million dollars with the Premier League.
Sorare’s fame, particularly over the past couple of years, has reached extraordinary levels. Similar to other emerging ventures, it combines fantasy gaming, non-fungible tokens, digital currencies, financial technology, and decentralized web technologies, which has also attracted the attention of gambling overseers like the French National Gambling Authority (ANJ).
Andrew Rhodes, the head of the UK Gambling Commission, recently voiced his concerns as well. In an address to gambling executives, he stated that the commission would be allocating more resources to determine whether synthetic stocks, cryptocurrency-backed NFTs, and other decentralized web-based products fall under the jurisdiction of gambling regulators.
This follows cautions issued to consumers in 2021, when the regulator initiated an inquiry into the business.
Concerning the ANJ, it has been in communication with Sorare regarding its business model since March. The regulator has decided to scrutinize it further to ascertain whether it constitutes offering real-money sports betting, akin to a bookmaker, or, perhaps more pertinent to Sorare, functions as a betting exchange.
**Fantasy Framework**
Sorare operates by issuing virtual player cards as non-fungible tokens. Users acquire these cards through the Ethereum platform and utilize them to create fantasy teams. These cards can be traded on Sorare’s digital marketplace/exchange, with their value fluctuating based on the real-life performance of the players on the field.
ANJ observed how well players performed in Sorare impacted the worth of the cards. This is not unexpected, as individuals must pay to participate in Sorare. Similar to other games where real money is utilized, individuals join Sorare fantasy leagues and invest funds, hoping to profit or incur losses.
Sorare’s leader, Nicolas Julia, stated that the money used to purchase cards does not constitute gambling, and the value of the cards is not connected to the performance of actual athletes.
He also asserted that Sorare players can retain their cards and utilize them repeatedly, but if one loses a sports wager, the money is permanently lost. This, he claimed, is another distinction between Sorare and sports betting.
**Concession**
In the middle of November, ANJ declared that Sorare consented to make its tournaments free to play more frequently. This was intended to address ANJ’s concerns regarding gambling regulations and their applicability to Sorare.
Sorare will not be required to obtain a sports betting license in France, but they must implement these modifications by March 31, 2023. ANJ indicated that this is a temporary solution, but it is crucial while they await the enactment of new laws concerning these emerging Web3 technologies. They aim to ensure that these novel technologies are appropriately regulated.
Sorare was questioned by iGB about their plans to make their “free access” strategy a reality. The company stated that their product will progress “by introducing new game options for users who don’t pay.”
The organization added: “Sorare is dedicated to innovation, and this advancement is part of the company’s strategy. This move will provide players with new gaming and tactical opportunities. This is advantageous for everyone, including current participants, as the Sorare community will expand.”
When asked if they anticipate their French market campaign to significantly decrease revenue, the company responded: “When you create a novel model like Sorare, it’s natural for the product to develop and enhance over time.
“Sorare is primarily a game. It is not presented or marketed as an investment or financial product. At present, 87% of our players participate for free. Our aim is to enlarge the community. There is no reason for the value of the cards to decline.”
The company clarified that the 87% figure refers to Sorare users who can purchase non-NFT cards, known as “common cards,” which they can use without cost when they join the platform. Naturally, this implies that Sorare users still need to buy the NFT cards that make up their “unique,” “rare,” or “limited edition” cards. Sorare informed iGB that they are unable to provide any additional details on this matter at this time.
The ascent of Sorare serves as a prime illustration of how nascent enterprises leverage cutting-edge technologies to craft products that regulatory bodies are ill-prepared for. Sorare stands as a compelling case in point.
Nevertheless, this subject matter carries significant weight in France. No legal professional within the French tech landscape would venture to engage in discourse on this matter. The implications are substantial for Sorare. Should the French gambling regulatory body (ANJ) determine that Sorare necessitates a sports wagering license, this could exert a considerable influence on its operations globally.
Another pivotal aspect of this deliberation revolves around the perspectives of players regarding the game. Irrespective of whether one perceives it as sports betting or financial investment, individuals participating in Sorare’s fantasy football competitions, or engaging in the purchase and sale of fan tokens on Socios, anticipate an appreciation in the value of their digital assets.
This is precisely why these Web3 ventures exhibit such fervent enthusiasm in sidestepping the label of gambling or financial investment. This also explains the ANJ’s declaration of harboring “grave reservations” concerning Sorare’s business model.
Sorare asserts that its product is accessible to all without cost. The true query lies in whether they will eliminate the mandate to acquire NFT cards for participation in their fantasy tournaments. This constitutes the most critical facet of the matter.
Therefore, it will be fascinating to observe how ANJ assesses the company’s endeavors to enhance free accessibility to its competitions in the March 2023 evaluation.
Sign up for the iGaming newsletter.
